Flexible working theory: what drawbacks should employers be aware of?

Written by Investors In People

Flexible working is here to stay. Even back in 1997, we  found that in every EU country the use of flexible working in all its forms was increasing, and that there was no sign this had peaked.

It is clear that there is value of flexible working in the workplace. There is a  positive correlation with higher levels of organisational commitment and job satisfaction. Increasing access to flexible working is a great thing for individual health, organisational success and the place of work in society. But, there are also potential drawbacks and actions that we will discuss.

Flexible working may worsen perceptions of performance

Research suggests employees physically observed by managers are judged to be more productive, given better performance evaluations and receive more promotions than those working off-site.

Of course, there’s no actual link between ‘face time’ and performance, but it’s the cognitive bias of giving preference to the observable that is responsible for the above effect, which can lead to disengagement, friction between employee and manager and reduced trust.

Flexible working may actually cause people to work more

While technology can empower people to work flexibly, it also blurs the boundaries between work time and leisure time.

We’ve discussed before the importance of setting boundaries in flexible working policies and managing by outcome in order to mitigate the potential for people to work more than if they maintained regular hours.

Just under half (45%) of the 1400 people surveyed by Orange Business Services said that working flexibly meant working more on weekends and evenings, so it’s important that organisations realise that those working flexibly may be at a higher risk of burnout.

Flexible working could increase conflict between work and home domains

Employees working from home may experience increased conflict between their work and home lives because they are in effect ‘available’ to both domains at the same time.

Further conflict may arise due to the removal of social connections with the workplace: the employee may feel ‘out of the loop’ with goings-on in the workplace, with associated feelings of loneliness and disengagement creeping in.

Flexible working may not help address the gender divide

Despite a rise in flexible working requests between 2006 and 2011, the gender balance between them did not change.

Women are more likely to request flexible working than men, parents are more likely to request flexible working than non-parents, and mothers are more likely to request flexible working than fathers.

Hooker et al (2007) found that parenthood had little effect on a man’s propensity towards flexible working, but a large effect on a woman’s.

And it’s not just that men are less likely to request flexible working: they are also less likely to have their requests accepted.

Flexible working may be perceived as career-limiting

Brandth and Elin Kvande (2001) found that male uptake of flexible working leave was inhibited by concerns about whether it would impact their career or not.

Furthermore, research from 2013 found that men were more likely to choose flexible working options that did not impact on face-time: there’s a good chance this is due to fears of a detrimental effect on their career.

Flexible working may be perceived as less available to managers

Back in 2004, the CIPD said that managers self-reported a lower level of flexibility inherent to their jobs, which may explain why they are less likely to request flexible working.

In the CIPD Flexible Working Outlook 2016, junior managers were the least likely group to work flexibly (42% used at least one form of flexible working), compared to 57% of employees with no management responsibility.

Hegewisch (2009) said that the methods of flexible working available to managers are most likely to be those that don’t reduce the number of hours worked, such as flexitime.

For Jones & Jones (2011), this issue is tied with gender: men are more likely to have requests for flexible working rejected because they are more likely to be in management positions that “do not lend themselves” to reduced hours or working away from the office.

Flexible working may not increase parental time with children

Organisations may increase flexible working to improve work-life balance and in turn retention.

But if parents take flexible working thinking it will lead to them spending more time with children, they may end up disappointed.

Baxter (2011) found that while flexible working benefits parents because of how it allows them to distribute their time, it doesn’t automatically increase the time they spend with children.

Organisations need to assist those working flexibly to drive the outcomes they are looking for, otherwise the positive effects of flexible working may be inhibited.

Take our 2-minute organisation wellbeing questionnaire

Beginner – your journey is just starting…


Thanks for completing our workplace wellbeing assessment! Don’t be disheartened by your result, the fact you’re considering employee wellbeing is a huge step in the right direction.

Here are some common themes we see when organisations are only just starting out on their wellbeing journey:
  • No strategy or poor buy in from executives
  • No goals or objectives or they’re poorly defined
  • No budget assigned to wellbeing
  • Company doesn’t consider all areas of wellbeing
  • Company doesn’t collect any data on wellbeing
  • Company doesn’t understand how to measure success


It’s great to see that you’ve made the commitment to start your wellbeing journey. If you take the time to plan, execute and measure your strategy you’ll start to see positive results.

We’re here to help you every step of the way – complete our enquiry form and our team will get in touch to see how we can help you!

Intermediate – you’re taking wellbeing seriously!

Thanks for completing our workplace wellbeing assessment. You can be pleased with your result, you value your employees wellbeing, your approach needs refining to get to the highest level.

Here are some common themes we see when organisations are making the right steps but need to refine them:
  • There is a strategy and execs buy into it, but it needs developing further to achieve your ambitions
  • There may be goals and objectives but they need refining
  • There is a budget assigned to wellbeing
  • Company may not consider all areas of wellbeing
  • Company struggles to collect and use wellbeing data
  • What defines success may be a little blurry


It’s great to see you’re making positive steps with your wellbeing plan. If you take the time to refine your strategy you’ll start to see even better results.

We’re here to help you every step of the way – complete our enquiry form and our team will get in touch to see how we can help you!

Advanced – your strategy is flying high!

Thanks for completing our workplace wellbeing assessment. You should be ecstatic, employee wellbeing is a key driver at your company and you’re doing everything on your own to promote it.

Here are some common themes we see in top organisations:
  • There is a clear strategy and executives actively promote it
  • There are clear goals and objectives – you know what you want to achieve
  • You have a budget that’s dedicated to wellbeing
  • You deliver in all areas of wellbeing
  • Your company collected data and uses it to inform your strategy
  • You have stealer KPIs and understand how they contribute to success


It’s great to see you’re making positive steps with your wellbeing plan. However, wellbeing can always be improved – so you’re in the perfect place to undertake our official wellbeing assessment!

Complete our enquiry form and our team will get in touch to talk you through our wellbeing accreditation.

START YOUR ACCREDITATION JOURNEY

Ready to make work better? Complete the form below and one of our team will be in touch to discuss your accreditation enquiry.

A problem was detected in the following Form. Submitting it could result in errors. Please contact the site administrator.

Thanks | #MAKEWORKBETTER

BEFORE YOU GO...

Hopefully you found what you were looking for. We’re always releasing new content and scheduling events to tackle some of the hottest topics in the news right now, so do check back soon.

Have you considered how your organisation would benefit from becoming accredited? Let’s talk! You can book a meeting directly using the link below.

Already accredited?

Please email support@investorsinpeople.com or phone us on 0300 303 3033 and we will deal with your enquiry promptly.